Things That Go Bump at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, Part Two: Shadows of the West Wing| The Strange History Podcast
Tonight's Episode
In the conclusion of our White House haunting special, Amy descends into the darker corners of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue—where the forgotten still knock, pace, and whisper.Meet the restless spirit of President William Henry Harrison, the stubborn landowner David Burnes, the grieving Anna Surratt who still begs for her mother’s pardon, and the British soldier eternally patrolling the lawn he once burned.
Then brace yourself for “The Thing”—the strangest haunting in White House history, the mysterious presence President Taft tried to banish by executive order.
With wit, historical depth, and eerie atmosphere, The Strange History Podcast reveals why America’s most powerful house is also its most haunted.
Press play, dear listeners. The Oval Office lights are flickering again.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-strange-history-podcast--5773362/support.
🎧 The Strange History Podcast Love bizarre true stories, forgotten scandals, and history’s most unhinged moments?
Submit your ideas for The Strange History Podcast
Follow The Strange History Podcast wherever you listen and never miss an episode. 🔗 Listen & Subscribe:
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeartRadio
Audible
New episodes regularly. History gets weird here.
Speaker 1: Welcome back, dear listeners, to part two of our White
Speaker 1: House Haunting series. Last time we met the presidential phantoms, Lincoln,
Speaker 1: Abigail Dolly, and the rest of the elite Afterlife Club.
Speaker 1: But tonight we're stepping into the other side of the
Speaker 1: mansion's history. The forgotten corners, the attic, the garden, the
Speaker 1: places the Secret Service doesn't list on the tour. Here's
Speaker 1: the truth. The White House isn't just haunted by the famous.
Speaker 1: It's haunted by the forgotten, the ones who died too quickly,
Speaker 1: were erased from memory, or simply refused to give up
Speaker 1: their view of the Rose Garden. So settle in light
Speaker 1: another founding Fragrance's candle. This one's called Oath of Office
Speaker 1: and Ominous Drafts. Because tonight, dear listeners, the halls are
Speaker 1: busier than you think.
Speaker 2: The shortest stay William Henry Harrison.
Speaker 1: In eighteen forty one, William Henry Harrison moved into the
Speaker 1: White House full of enthusiasm and without a coat. He
Speaker 1: gave the longest inaugural address in US history, standing in
Speaker 1: cold March rain for nearly two hours. A month later,
Speaker 1: he was dead of pneumonia. The shortest presidency in American history,
Speaker 1: just thirty one days, and yet, according to more than
Speaker 1: a century of reports, he never left. White House. Staff
Speaker 1: say the attic above the second floor sometimes echoes with slow,
Speaker 1: deliberate footsteps. One nineteen forties usher claimed he heard drawers
Speaker 1: open and shut when no one was there. Another said
Speaker 1: he felt someone breathing behind him as he inventoried old furniture,
Speaker 1: but when he turned there was only dust, motes and
Speaker 1: cold air. Even modern maintenance crews have commented on a
Speaker 1: man walking up there no pranksters, no intruders, just a
Speaker 1: lonely sound of someone searching through trunks, perhaps still unpacking
Speaker 1: for a presidency that never began. Harrison's ghost is less
Speaker 1: of a fright and more of a sigh, a reminder
Speaker 1: that sometimes the briefest stories echo the loudest. He didn't
Speaker 1: get to make history, so he made the guest list instead.
Speaker 2: The land's original owner, David Burns.
Speaker 1: Before there was a White House, there was farmland, And
Speaker 1: before there was farmland, there was David Burns, the stubborn
Speaker 1: Scottish farmer who owned the land that George Washington wanted
Speaker 1: for his new capital city. Burns didn't go quietly. He
Speaker 1: refused to sell, at first, earning himself the nickname the
Speaker 1: obstinate Mister Burns. Eventually, after some heated negotiations and a
Speaker 1: bit of presidential persuasion, he relented, but perhaps not happily.
Speaker 1: For over a century, guards and staff have reported hearing
Speaker 1: a gruff male voice in the Yellow Oval Room or
Speaker 1: near the South portico, muttering about my land or what
Speaker 1: they've done to it. In nineteen oh three, a night
Speaker 1: watchman swore he saw an older man in eighteenth century close,
Speaker 1: pacing and gesturing towards the city beyond the gates. When
Speaker 1: the watchman approached, the man vanished, leaving behind only the
Speaker 1: faint smell of pipe smoke. Some ghosts cling to people,
Speaker 1: others cling to property lines, and honestly, in DC, that's
Speaker 1: probably the most relatable haunting of all.
Speaker 2: The daughter who kept knocking, Anna Surrett.
Speaker 1: Few stories in American history are as tragic as Anna Surret's.
Speaker 1: Her mother, Mary Surrett, owned the boarding house where John
Speaker 1: Wilkes Booth and his conspirators plotted Lincoln's assassination. When the
Speaker 1: government rounded them up, Mary was convicted and sentenced to hang.
Speaker 1: Desperate to save her, Anna spent the night before the execution,
Speaker 1: pounding on the White House doors, begging President Andrew Johnson
Speaker 1: for clemency. The guards refused to wake him. The next morning,
Speaker 1: Mary Surrat was hanged, the first woman ever executed by
Speaker 1: the US government. Years later, guards began hearing frantic knocking
Speaker 1: on the North Portico doors, especially in the humid summer
Speaker 1: months when the air felt heavy with memory. Some claimed
Speaker 1: they heard a woman's voice crying, let me in. Others
Speaker 1: described the doorknobs rattling violently, as if someone were still outside,
Speaker 1: still begging. There's something heartbreakingly human about Anna's haunting. She's
Speaker 1: not a wandering spirit. She's a memory that refuses to fade.
Speaker 1: If you ever stand before the North Portico late at
Speaker 1: night and hear a faint tapping, you might be listening
Speaker 1: to history still trying to rewrite itself.
Speaker 3: Tonight's episode is brought to you by Presidential Poltergeist Tours,
Speaker 3: because democracy is fun, but ghosts don't filibuster. Book your
Speaker 3: trip today and get our exclusive souvenir mug I survived
Speaker 3: the Lincoln Bedroom Barely. Use promo code Spooky spous at
Speaker 3: check out for ten percent off your honk.
Speaker 2: The Unfinished War, The British soldier in eighteen fourteen.
Speaker 1: During the War of eighteen twelve, British troops marched into
Speaker 1: Washington and set fire to nearly every public building, including
Speaker 1: the White House. Legend says that one of those soldiers
Speaker 1: never left. Guards have reported seeing a shadowy figure in
Speaker 1: a red coat patrolling the north lawn, musket on shoulder,
Speaker 1: face obscured. Some call him the smoking Man because witnesses
Speaker 1: often see a faint wisp of smoke drifting up from
Speaker 1: where his pipe glows in the dark. In nineteen fifty three,
Speaker 1: a Marine sentry on duty swore he saw the figure
Speaker 1: cross the lawn, salute and vanish. Another decades later chased
Speaker 1: what he thought was an intruder, only to find the
Speaker 1: footprints ended abruptly in soft grass. Maybe he's a soldier
Speaker 1: still on guard duty, protecting the place he once destroyed.
Speaker 1: Or maybe he's just very, very lost, like a Britage
Speaker 1: tourists trying to find the nearest pub. Either way, I
Speaker 1: hope someone's told him the war's over.
Speaker 2: The Romantic Return, John Tyler.
Speaker 1: The Blue Room of the White House is one of
Speaker 1: the most elegant chambers, the sight of receptions, holiday photos,
Speaker 1: and one ghostly love story. President John Tyler, widowed during
Speaker 1: his term, became the first president to marry while in office.
Speaker 1: He proposed to his young bride, Julia Gardner, right in
Speaker 1: the Blue Room in eighteen forty four. Long after his death,
Speaker 1: Musicians performing during holiday events reported feeling a tap on
Speaker 1: the shoulder and no one there. One clarinetist said he
Speaker 1: felt a cold hand push his elbow just as he
Speaker 1: played a wrong note, as though someone disapproved of his tune.
Speaker 1: During Christmas tours, visitors have described a sudden hush falling
Speaker 1: over the Blue Room, as if a private moment is
Speaker 1: being replayed in time. If the White House can be
Speaker 1: a battlefield, it can also be a ballroom. And if
Speaker 1: anyone deserves a lingering encore, it's a president who found
Speaker 1: love again in the middle of his presidency. The original
Speaker 1: Oval Office rom com.
Speaker 3: This episode is sponsored by Seance Safe tablecloths, stain resistant,
Speaker 3: candle friendly and guaranteed not to burst into flames during
Speaker 3: contact with the spirit realm. Sayance safe, because when you're
Speaker 3: raising the dead, presentation matters.
Speaker 2: The thing in the White House.
Speaker 1: Now, dear listeners, we come to perhaps the strangest haunting
Speaker 1: in the entire White House the thing. Between nineteen eleven
Speaker 1: and nineteen twelve, staff members began reporting something unseen, a
Speaker 1: presence that would press lightly on their shoulders, as if
Speaker 1: someone tall were peering over them. They described a feeling
Speaker 1: of cold curiosity, and then nothing. Soon rumors spread, maids
Speaker 1: refused to go into certain rooms alone, Butler's claimed to
Speaker 1: see a boy with messy hair and sad blue eyes
Speaker 1: darting through the halls. One maid, Florence Marsh, swore she
Speaker 1: saw him standing by the staircase one morning, pale, silent,
Speaker 1: watching her, before vanishing. When President William Howard Taft caught
Speaker 1: wind of the hysteria, he ordered everyone to stop talking
Speaker 1: about it. No ghosts in my administration, he said, firmly,
Speaker 1: But privately, he reportedly told his military aid to find
Speaker 1: out what in the devil they're seeing. No answer, ever, came.
Speaker 1: After nineteen twelve, the sighting stopped, but even now staff
Speaker 1: occasionally mention a strange sense of being watched in the
Speaker 1: West Wing corridors late at night, a feeling that something
Speaker 1: is almost there.
Speaker 2: What was it?
Speaker 1: A trick of light, collective imagination, the ghost of Willie
Speaker 1: Lincoln playing hide and seek? Or maybe and this is
Speaker 1: my favorite theory. The thing is the White House itself
Speaker 1: a living, breathing memory of power and consequence, because after
Speaker 1: two centuries of triumph, tragedy, and laundry, maybe the House
Speaker 1: doesn't just remember. Maybe it observes every era leaves a
Speaker 1: fingerprint on that building, every choice, every laugh, every secret.
Speaker 1: The White House isn't haunted because it's old. It's haunted
Speaker 1: because it's alive with history. And that history has a
Speaker 1: way of walking the halls when the lights go out.
Speaker 1: So next time you see a shadow move in a
Speaker 1: photo from the Lincoln Bedroom, or you hear music in
Speaker 1: an empty hall, or you get the sudden urge to
Speaker 1: knock on a locked door, remember you're in good company. Presidents, first, ladies, soldiers, children,
Speaker 1: They all left something behind. I'm Amy and this has
Speaker 1: been the Strange History podcast Things that Go Bump at
Speaker 1: sixteen hundred Pennsylvania Avenue. If you enjoyed our little ghost tour, subscribe,
Speaker 1: leave a review, and maybe send a candle to the
Speaker 1: Lincoln bedroom. He's been working late for one hundred and
Speaker 1: sixty years. Good Night, dear listeners, and if you ever
Speaker 1: get invited to stay overnight at the White House, keep
Speaker 1: your slippers by the bed. You never know who'll be
Speaker 1: walking past your door.
Podbean