Coincidence? I Think Not! 12 Bizarre Historical Twists
Tonight's Episode
In this episode of The Strange History Podcast, Amy dives into twelve jaw-dropping historical coincidences that are so weird, they sound made up. From twins living eerily parallel lives, to founding fathers syncing their final exit, to a war that couldn’t seem to leave one poor guy’s house alone — these real-life stories will make you laugh, gasp, and maybe side-eye the universe just a little. Perfect for fans of the mysterious, the absurd, and the historically uncanny. Come for the facts, stay for the sass.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-strange-history-podcast--5773362/support.
🎧 The Strange History Podcast Love bizarre true stories, forgotten scandals, and history’s most unhinged moments?
Submit your ideas for The Strange History Podcast
Follow The Strange History Podcast wherever you listen and never miss an episode. 🔗 Listen & Subscribe:
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeartRadio
Audible
New episodes regularly. History gets weird here.
Speaker 1: Hey, hey, curious minds, Welcome back to the Strange History Podcast.
Speaker 1: I'm your host, Amy, and today we're diving headfirst into
Speaker 1: the weirdest corners of history. And not just any history.
Speaker 1: I'm talking the wait, what kind the ones that make
Speaker 1: you go that can't be real but somehow totally are.
Speaker 1: If you're new here, welcome, You're in for a ride.
Speaker 1: And if you're a returning listener, Hi again, you little weirdo.
Speaker 1: And I mean that lovingly. You know we love a
Speaker 1: good mystery around here. Today's episode it's all about historical
Speaker 1: coincidences that are so bananas they'll make you question whether
Speaker 1: reality is glitching. So go ahead, grab your drink, pet
Speaker 1: your cat, put your phone on silent, and let's get
Speaker 1: into twelve truly bizarre moments in history that are just
Speaker 1: way too perfectly weird.
Speaker 2: Hey, Strange history lovers, my name is Dan and I
Speaker 2: will be doing a bit of narration on the podcast.
Speaker 2: Amy is paying me in homemade baked goods. No judging please.
Speaker 2: The Hoover Dam's spooky symmetry.
Speaker 1: Okay, this one gave me chills. When they started building
Speaker 1: the Hoover Dam back in the early nineteen twenties, The
Speaker 1: very first death on the site was a guy named J. G. Tierney.
Speaker 1: Poor guy drowned on December twentieth, nineteen twenty two. Now
Speaker 1: fast forward thirteen years to the day, December twentieth, nineteen
Speaker 1: thirty five. The last person to die during construction Patrick Tierney,
Speaker 1: his son, same date, thirteen years apart. Both father and
Speaker 1: son died working on the same project. That's not just tragic,
Speaker 1: that's horror movie level timing, like the dam was keeping
Speaker 1: score or something.
Speaker 2: The most synchronized twins ever.
Speaker 1: So in Ohio, two identical twin boys were adopted by
Speaker 1: different families after being separated at birth. Neither family knew
Speaker 1: about the other. But here's where it gets into the
Speaker 1: twilight zone. Both adoptive families named their sons James. One
Speaker 1: became a security guard, the other a deputy sheriff, so
Speaker 1: kind of the same vibe. Both married women named Linda,
Speaker 1: then both got divorced. Then both married women named Betty
Speaker 1: like really Betty. Each had a son named James Allen.
Speaker 1: They drove the same Chevy automobile, smoked the same brand
Speaker 1: of cigarettes, and vacationed at the same beach in Florida.
Speaker 1: They didn't meet until they were thirty nine at that point.
Speaker 1: It's not even coincidence. It's just fate doing a weird flex.
Speaker 2: The bullet with a personal vendetta.
Speaker 1: Henry Ziegland, a man in Texas in the late eighteen hundreds,
Speaker 1: breaks up with his girlfriend. She's heartbroken and sadly ends
Speaker 1: her life. Her brother, understandably furious, tries to shoot Henry.
Speaker 1: He fires the shot but misses. The bullet lodges in
Speaker 1: a tree behind Henry, so Henry lives. Years later. Henry's like,
Speaker 1: I want this tree gone, and he doesn't just chop
Speaker 1: it down. He uses dynamite as one does. The explosion
Speaker 1: sends the exact same bullet flying, and it hits Henry
Speaker 1: in the head. That time it doesn't miss. That's not
Speaker 1: just karma. That's karma with a sniper rifle and a
Speaker 1: long attention span.
Speaker 2: Lincoln and Kennedy history's favorite echo.
Speaker 1: You've probably heard this one, but it never gets old.
Speaker 1: The Lincoln Kennedy coincidences are chef's kiss weird. Lincoln was
Speaker 1: elected in eighteen sixty, Kennedy he was elected in nineteen sixty.
Speaker 1: Lincoln's VP and eventual successor was Andrew Johnson, and he
Speaker 1: was born in eighteen oh eight. Kennedy's VP and successor,
Speaker 1: Lyndon B. Johnson, born in nineteen oh eight. Both were
Speaker 1: assassinated on a Friday, both shot in the head. Both
Speaker 1: killers had three names fifteen letters. John Wilkes Booth, Lee
Speaker 1: Harvey Oswald. Booth shot Lincoln in a theater and fled
Speaker 1: to a warehouse. Oswald shot Kennedy from a warehouse and
Speaker 1: fled to a theater. It's like history just hit copy paste,
Speaker 1: changed a few names, and called it a sequel.
Speaker 2: The book that predicted the Titanic.
Speaker 1: In eighteen ninety eight, author Morgan Robertson writes a novella
Speaker 1: called Futility. It's about a massive ocean liner called the
Speaker 1: titan Yeah, not the Titanic, but close that was considered unsinkable.
Speaker 1: Guess what happens. Yep, it hits an iceberg in April
Speaker 1: and sinks. Fourteen years later, the Titanic sets sail. It's huge,
Speaker 1: it's unsinkable, it doesn't have enough lifeboats. But wait, the
Speaker 1: ship hits an iceberg in April, and yep, it goes down,
Speaker 1: sinks like a stone. Robertson's swore it was just imagination,
Speaker 1: but man that is some suspiciously specific fiction.
Speaker 2: The baby dry Yes, I said, Baby Dropper.
Speaker 1: Detroit, nineteen thirties. A guy named Joseph Figlock, real person,
Speaker 1: not a cartoon character, is sweeping an alley when a
Speaker 1: baby falls out of a fourth story window lands right
Speaker 1: on him. Both survive, thankfully, and then get this. A
Speaker 1: year later, in the same alley, another baby falls out
Speaker 1: of a window onto Joseph Figlock again, and they both
Speaker 1: survive again. I don't know what's more surprising that he
Speaker 1: survived two surprise babies or that babies in the nineteen
Speaker 1: thirties were just casually falling out of windows.
Speaker 2: One tree, two wars, same family.
Speaker 1: During World War One, a British soldier narrowly avoids death
Speaker 1: when a dudshell smacks into a tree instead of well him.
Speaker 1: He's so grateful to the tree he carves his name
Speaker 1: into the bark. Fast forward to World War Two. His son,
Speaker 1: also a soldier, finds shelter behind that same tree. He
Speaker 1: sees the carving and oh my gosh, he finds his
Speaker 1: dad's name. It's like the tree was like, Hey, I
Speaker 1: got you, guys, generational trauma. I am your leafy therapist.
Speaker 2: Frane Selac literally too lucky to die.
Speaker 1: Fraine Celac, a Croatian music teacher, might be the luckiest
Speaker 1: or most targeted by fate. Man alive, he survives a
Speaker 1: train crash that kills seventeen. A year later, he's ejected
Speaker 1: from a crashing airplane and lands safely in a haystack.
Speaker 1: Then he survives a bus crash two separate car explosions,
Speaker 1: gets hit by a bus again, nearly gets hit by
Speaker 1: a truck, and then, as if the universe was like okay, okay,
Speaker 1: we get it, he wins the lottery. Like this man
Speaker 1: didn't just dodge death, he sprinted past it and flipped
Speaker 1: it the bird.
Speaker 2: Edgar Allan Poe time traveler.
Speaker 1: In eighteen thirty eight, Poe writes a novel called The
Speaker 1: Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pim. It includes a shipwreck, a
Speaker 1: group of survivors, and a guy named Richard Parker who
Speaker 1: gets eaten fictional story. Then, in eighteen eighty four, the
Speaker 1: real life yacht Mignonette sinks. The survivors you guessed it,
Speaker 1: end up eating the cabin boy. His name, Richard freaking Parker.
Speaker 1: Like what kind of psychic seafood nightmare did Poe tap into.
Speaker 2: That one taxi in Bermuda.
Speaker 1: The scene is set in Bermuda. A guy on a
Speaker 1: moped is hit by a taxi dies tragically. One year later,
Speaker 1: his brother, riding the same moped down the same street,
Speaker 1: is hit by the same taxi driven by the same
Speaker 1: driver carrying the same passenger. At that point, that moped
Speaker 1: needs to be exercised or just thrown into the ocean.
Speaker 2: Founding Fathers sink up one last time.
Speaker 1: Thomas Jefferson and John Adams were like that odd couple
Speaker 1: who went from bestie's to rivals and back to bros.
Speaker 1: They both played massive roles in founding the US, both
Speaker 1: served as president, both retired around the same time, and
Speaker 1: then on July fourth, eighteen twenty six, the fiftieth anniversary
Speaker 1: of the Declaration of Independence, they both died hours apart.
Speaker 1: Adam's last words were supposedly Thomas Jefferson survives, except Jefferson
Speaker 1: had actually died a few hours earlier. It's like they
Speaker 1: planned one last synchronized mic drop Founding Fathers, but make
Speaker 1: it dramatic civil war.
Speaker 2: The house it wouldn't leave alone.
Speaker 1: Wilma McLain just wanted some peace in quiet in eighteen
Speaker 1: sixty one, the First Battle of bull Run literally exploded
Speaker 1: in his front yard. Cannonballs, chaos, the works. So he
Speaker 1: moves away all the way to Appomattox, Virginia. Nice quiet
Speaker 1: town until four years later when General Robert E. Lee
Speaker 1: surrendered to Ulysses S. Grant in yep, McLean's living room.
Speaker 1: The war started in his front yard and ended in
Speaker 1: his parlor. His exact words, the.
Speaker 2: War began in my front yard and ended in my
Speaker 2: front parlor.
Speaker 1: I mean, come on, that man just could not escape
Speaker 1: the plot. So there you go. Twelve times the universe
Speaker 1: decided to be extra weird. Whether it's a psychic poet,
Speaker 1: a bullet with a memory, or the founding Fathers doing
Speaker 1: one last patriotic high five from beyond the grave. History
Speaker 1: has a wild sense of humor. If you had fun today,
Speaker 1: don't forget to follow. Leave a little love in the reviews,
Speaker 1: or send this to your friend who always dominates trivia night.
Speaker 1: Got a strange history nugget of your own, Slide into
Speaker 1: my inbox. You might just hear it on a future episode.
Speaker 2: Until next time, Stay curious, stay weird, and remember sometimes
Speaker 2: the past is stranger than fiction, and occasionally it drops
Speaker 2: a baby on your head. And now I am off
Speaker 2: to collect my baked bribery goods that Amy baked. It's
Speaker 2: the only way I would do this. We are friends,
Speaker 2: but not that good of friends. Just sayin
Podbean